Today checked my statement online for the hell of it. Saw a charge placed yesterday pending for $206.06 to buy.com. I remember my purchases, and that wasn't one of them...
Called buy.com and they sent me to the fraud department who said it was already on hold because the order was going to another state. They canceled the order. Called the bank and canceled the card.
Now, a vast majority of my purchases are on a few sites that I have used for years without issue, so I doubt it was taken online. My other purchases are usually at work on the arsenal, or gas stations, with people I've dealt with for years, so I doubt it's them. The only "unusual" places I've charged my card lately was Burger King on the Arsenal, our fancy new Panda Express (first one here), and a gas station just the other day. Don't think it was the BK because I saw the entire swiping process and didn't notice anything unusual. Don't think it was Panda Express because she looked too dumb for that, although I was concerned with the length of time she had my card... The gas station here, the guy fits my imagined profile of the geeky type person that would steal a card number, use it on a site like buy.com, and have enough sense to ship to another state.
I have multiple credit cards, but the others I haven't used at all in months because their interest rate is higher than my bank's and they don't have any rewards. I plan to go to all the places I suspect of swiping my card number, and if the same employee is working I'll give them one of my very-rarely-used cards, along with ample opportunity to take the number. If some bullshit charge shows up again, I know who to introduce the baseball bat...or what else is suggested?